Add to favorites
Skip to product information
1 of 0

Eagle Spice

Ground Allspice

Ground Allspice

Eagle Spice Ground Allspice delivers the warm, layered flavor that gives allspice its name, in a case buil... Read more

Eagle Spice Ground Allspice delivers the warm, layered flavor that gives allspice its name, in a case built for kitchens that go through it steadily. One berry carries notes that read as cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove at once, which is why it turns up in everything from jerk seasoning to gingerbread. Packed as a case of six 5 lb units, available in bulk and wholesale quantities.


What It Is

Allspice is a single spice, not a blend, despite what the name suggests to most people who have not cooked with it. It is the dried unripe berry of the Pimenta dioica tree, native to Jamaica and the wider Caribbean, picked green and dried until it darkens and hardens. Ground allspice is those berries milled to a fine powder, ready to go straight into a dough, a rub, or a batter without the steeping step whole berries require.


Flavor and Aroma

The flavor sits at the crossroads of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, with a faint peppery bite behind it and a resinous depth that keeps it from reading as purely sweet. It is potent, so it works as a supporting note more often than a lead one. In baking it fills out a spice blend and rounds off the sharper edges of ginger and clove, and in savory cooking it brings warmth without adding heat.


Culinary Uses

Allspice crosses the sweet and savory line more easily than most warm spices:

  • Gingerbread, spice cake, and pumpkin pie
  • Cookies, muffins, and holiday baking
  • Mincemeat, fruitcake, and preserves
  • Jerk seasoning and Caribbean marinades
  • Sausage, charcuterie, and meat rubs
  • Pickling brines and barbecue sauces
  • Middle Eastern rice and braised meat dishes
  • Mulled cider, mulled wine, and spiced syrups

It is a workhorse in a bakery spice cabinet through the fall, since almost every seasonal blend leans on it whether or not the recipe card says so by name.


How It Performs in the Kitchen

Ground allspice disperses evenly through dry ingredients, so it goes in with the flour rather than being added late. It is strong enough that a heavy hand turns a batter medicinal, and in blends it tends to want less than cinnamon and more than clove. Toasting is unnecessary and generally counterproductive with an already ground spice, since the volatile oils are what carry the flavor.


Storage and Handling

Keep containers sealed in a cool dry place away from the range, the oven line, and direct light. Ground spices lose their aromatics faster than whole ones do, and heat and open air accelerate it, so a 5 lb unit is best opened only as the previous one runs out rather than all six at once.


Bulk and Wholesale Options

This item ships as a case of six 5 lb units. Bakeries, commissaries, and production kitchens can order in bulk at wholesale by the case or by the pallet, with quantity pricing available on larger orders.


Brand

Eagle Spice is a New York spice house supplying ground spices, whole spices, blends, and seasonings, with pure spices and no artificial additives as the line's stated position. Their range runs across the baking staples along with the savory side of the cabinet.


Product Identifier

Item Number: D-2189


Key Takeaways

  • Ground allspice, the dried berry of the Pimenta dioica tree
  • Warm flavor reading as cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove together
  • Works across baking, jerk seasoning, charcuterie, pickling, and mulled drinks
  • Ready to use with no steeping or grinding step
  • Case of six 5 lb units, available in bulk and wholesale
Read Less
Regular price $362.43
Regular price Sale price $362.43
Sale Sold out
View full details

Eagle Spice Ground Allspice delivers the warm, layered flavor that gives allspice its name, in a case built for kitchens that go through it steadily. One berry carries notes that read as cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove at once, which is why it turns up in everything from jerk seasoning to gingerbread. Packed as a case of six 5 lb units, available in bulk and wholesale quantities.


What It Is

Allspice is a single spice, not a blend, despite what the name suggests to most people who have not cooked with it. It is the dried unripe berry of the Pimenta dioica tree, native to Jamaica and the wider Caribbean, picked green and dried until it darkens and hardens. Ground allspice is those berries milled to a fine powder, ready to go straight into a dough, a rub, or a batter without the steeping step whole berries require.


Flavor and Aroma

The flavor sits at the crossroads of cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove, with a faint peppery bite behind it and a resinous depth that keeps it from reading as purely sweet. It is potent, so it works as a supporting note more often than a lead one. In baking it fills out a spice blend and rounds off the sharper edges of ginger and clove, and in savory cooking it brings warmth without adding heat.


Culinary Uses

Allspice crosses the sweet and savory line more easily than most warm spices:

  • Gingerbread, spice cake, and pumpkin pie
  • Cookies, muffins, and holiday baking
  • Mincemeat, fruitcake, and preserves
  • Jerk seasoning and Caribbean marinades
  • Sausage, charcuterie, and meat rubs
  • Pickling brines and barbecue sauces
  • Middle Eastern rice and braised meat dishes
  • Mulled cider, mulled wine, and spiced syrups

It is a workhorse in a bakery spice cabinet through the fall, since almost every seasonal blend leans on it whether or not the recipe card says so by name.


How It Performs in the Kitchen

Ground allspice disperses evenly through dry ingredients, so it goes in with the flour rather than being added late. It is strong enough that a heavy hand turns a batter medicinal, and in blends it tends to want less than cinnamon and more than clove. Toasting is unnecessary and generally counterproductive with an already ground spice, since the volatile oils are what carry the flavor.


Storage and Handling

Keep containers sealed in a cool dry place away from the range, the oven line, and direct light. Ground spices lose their aromatics faster than whole ones do, and heat and open air accelerate it, so a 5 lb unit is best opened only as the previous one runs out rather than all six at once.


Bulk and Wholesale Options

This item ships as a case of six 5 lb units. Bakeries, commissaries, and production kitchens can order in bulk at wholesale by the case or by the pallet, with quantity pricing available on larger orders.


Brand

Eagle Spice is a New York spice house supplying ground spices, whole spices, blends, and seasonings, with pure spices and no artificial additives as the line's stated position. Their range runs across the baking staples along with the savory side of the cabinet.


Product Identifier

Item Number: D-2189


Key Takeaways

  • Ground allspice, the dried berry of the Pimenta dioica tree
  • Warm flavor reading as cinnamon, nutmeg, and clove together
  • Works across baking, jerk seasoning, charcuterie, pickling, and mulled drinks
  • Ready to use with no steeping or grinding step
  • Case of six 5 lb units, available in bulk and wholesale

Frequently Asked Questions

What can you substitute for ground allspice?
Equal parts cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves gets close, since those are the notes people read in it. It will not be exact, because allspice carries a peppery, resinous edge that the three together do not reproduce, but in a spice cake or a cookie dough the difference is small.
When should you use whole allspice instead of ground?
Whole berries suit anything with liquid and time, like pickling brines, mulled cider, braises, and stocks, where they release slowly and can be strained out. Ground is for doughs, batters, and rubs, where the spice has to distribute rather than steep.
Is allspice the same as pumpkin pie spice?
No. Pumpkin pie spice is a blend, usually cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves, and many versions include allspice as one component. Allspice on its own is a single spice from a single berry.
Why is allspice also called pimento or Jamaican pepper?
Spanish explorers in the Caribbean mistook the dried berries for peppercorns and called them pimienta. The name stuck, which is why Jamaican recipes and packaging often say pimento even though the spice has no relation to black pepper or to the pimiento pepper.
What is the difference between allspice and cloves?
They share eugenol, the compound behind that warm medicinal note, which is why they read as related. Cloves are far more intense and can dominate a formula quickly, while allspice is rounder and more forgiving, carrying some of the same character with cinnamon and nutmeg alongside it.